I have many favorite sock yarns -- because I have many favorite styles
of sock!
I have a love-hate relationship with Schaefer Anne. I love the yarn,
but it is so fine that I need to knit it on 1.5 mm needles. (That's 000
in US sizes.) So it takes me a lot longer to make a pair of Anne socks.
On the other hand, I can make a pair of socks in my size and still have
plenty left over from a hank, so I don't need to worry about dividing it
in half and knitting toe-up.
I like Opal and Regia self-patterning yarns. It seems to me that Opal
is a bit smoother and Regia is a bit rougher, but they both make good
socks. And Opal (even though it doesn't say so on the label) wears like
iron and is machine washable. I don't like all the colorways, but I
think both yarns come in a broad enough variety that I can find
colorways I like.
I like Austermann Step; it's a bit splitty to work with, so I have to
pay more attention. I think I like the socks, too; I made myself a
pair, and somehow they seem to find themselves on someone else's feet
more often than on mine. So someone likes the socks, which is good.
They do require special care: the yarn has aloe and jojoba infused into
it somehow, which means that you can't wash them with fabric softener.
I like the hand-dyed yarns that Ray Whiting (http://www.knitivity.com)
produces -- beautiful, rich combinations of colors. The base yarn he
uses is a little bit splitty, but not that much more so than Austermann
Step, and the colors are rich and permanent -- I've probably washed one
pair of socks from his yarn 15 times, and it's still just as brightly
colored as it was the day I finished knitting it.
All of these are great yarns for plain St st socks - the sort of socks I
keep in my shoulder bag for when I'm on the bus or train, or when I have
to wait in line somewhere. No complicated patterns, stuff I can do from
memory.
But I like more complicated socks too....
I like Briggs & Little Durasport a great deal. It's a rustic
single-strand yarn, 20% nylon (or thereabouts, maybe 15%, maybe 25%, my
memory's not perfect) that's not heavily processed -- you will be
picking bits of grass out of it now and then. It's very well suited for
colorwork socks (though their Sport line, which is 100% wool, comes in a
much broader range of colors). It's also quite good for Aran or cable
knit socks. I have tried lace socks with it, and I think it's a little
too fuzzy to get good stitch definition.
(I've also found that the B&L Heritage and Regal yarn lines, 100% wool
in a 2-ply yarn, are an almost ideal for Aran sweater knitting.)
I also like Bartlett Sport (http://www.bartlettyarns.com) a great deal.
It's a two-ply, light sport weight or heavy sock weight yarn. It comes
in one-pound cones, so it's a bit of a commitment, but the colors are so
rich and heathery that it's an easy commitment to get into. It's great
for colorwork socks. It seems like it should be great for Aran socks
too, but I haven't tried that yet.
And I like Tongue River Farm icelandic sock wool.
(http://www.icelandicsheep.com) It comes in a variety of natural colors
- a cream-colored off-white, a rich brown, a cool grey. I've knit a
colorwork sock in two natural colors, and it is beautiful and warm and
soft. I want to try this yarn with icelandic socks too.
So I guess I'm just incapable of being faithful to one sock yarn.
(a post I made to the Socknitters list on 27 December 2007 in response to a question about "what is your favorite sock yarn?")